Steiner seeks anchor tenant before waterfront construction

Brian Dentz

Steiner seeks anchor tenant before waterfront construction
Undeveloped land at the proposed film studio site near First Avenue on the Sunset Park waterfront. Photo by Brian Dentz

For more than four decades, Phil DiPietro has run a screen-printing and embroidery business on Sunset Park's waterfront. T-shirts are APSCO's bread and butter, whether the order comes from a local deli or a professional sports team.

“When the Knicks won, and they put the shirt on, on the court, it comes from Brooklyn, New York, right from my backyard, right here,” DiPietro said of the work produced by his company, now housed in a 40,000-square-foot facility at the Brooklyn Army Terminal.

But in 2023, APSCO had to leave its longtime home in Building 57 at First Avenue and 50th Street to make way for a planned film and television production complex. The business moved roughly a dozen blocks south. DiPietro called the relocation “a crushing blow.”

“Only the act and the grace of God was I able to come through all of the troubling times,” he said.

The company's former building, near Bush Terminal Park, and its current home at 140 58th Street, Building B, Unit 1G, in the Brooklyn Army Terminal are city-owned properties managed by the New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC), a nonprofit development organization that manages industrial and other assets across the city.

In August 2020, NYCEDC announced that it had selected Steiner Studios to develop and operate a 500,000-square-foot film and television production hub at the Made in New York Campus in Bush Terminal. The plan called for $320 million in private investment, eight new soundstages and extensive renovations to two existing buildings, including one that had housed APSCO.

The city projected the completed complex would support 2,200 industry jobs, including set builders, electricians, scenic artists, grips, prop masters, set dressers, hair and makeup artists and costume designers. The announcement also anticipated 1,800 construction jobs, a playground at Bush Terminal Park and training or internship opportunities for local high school students.

Relocating a factory full of heavy equipment was expensive and disruptive, DiPietro said. “EDC gave me a concession, which wasn't a lot. I mean, wasn't enough.” Other tenants using the building for storage also had to leave, according to DiPietro.

APSCO produces apparel for brands such as Marc Ecko's, as well as shirts for neighborhood pizza shops, delis and sports teams. DiPietro said it employs about 40 workers, most of whom live in Sunset Park. The company is an example of the industrial businesses that local officials and nonprofits have argued can provide jobs for the neighborhood's immigrant workforce.

Six years after the studio announcement, two buildings near First Avenue and 50th Street remain vacant, with broken windows. A tattered sign still bears part of APSCO's name and the words “screen” and “embroidery.” The promised complex has yet to take shape.

“We do not have any updates to share,” NYCEDC told the Sunset Post when asked about the project's status. “EDC remains committed to advancing a project that supports economic growth, creates jobs and drives long-term investment in Sunset Park.”

A spokesperson for Steiner Studios gave a more specific explanation: “Steiner Sequel in Sunset Park is working to land an anchor tenant before breaking ground.”

Why is finding that tenant difficult? The Sunset Post spoke with Anthony Jasenski of commercial real estate firm CBRE, who focuses on the film industry's property needs. Sunset Park remains “absolutely a viable location” for soundstages because, he said, it is close to the city center and transportation, advantages for both on-camera performers and production crews. He said the site could be especially useful for episodic television production.

Demand, however, has changed since the project was announced. Jasenski recalled a period when nearly every studio, from newly built soundstages to converted warehouses, was close to fully occupied, with productions lined up.

The writers' and actors' strikes in 2023 disrupted that market. “Everything went empty for almost an entire year, across the country, not even just New York,” he said. “Because no one could work.”

Production has returned, but Jasenski said New York's recovery has been uneven, while incentives in countries including Canada and the United Kingdom have attracted work away from the United States.

Higher borrowing costs also make developers more cautious about building new facilities, he said.

“But the sensitivities are much greater now,” Jasenski said. “It needs to be the right time. And realistically, if you're not already building it, it may be reasonable to wait until our conditions continue to improve.”

A proposed federal tax incentive for film and television production could strengthen the U.S. industry if it were enacted, Jasenski went on to say. For the Sunset Park project, though, the immediate unanswered question is when Steiner will secure the anchor tenant it says it needs.

Steiner's plans also called for a playground in Bush Terminal Park, the waterfront park adjacent to the proposed studio complex. At an October 8 NYCEDC economic development town hall, Community Board 7 member Katie Walsh asked when the playground promised under the community benefits agreement would be built.

“We're working on transferring those funds and mobilizing construction next year,” NYCEDC's Gabriel Lefferts responded. He estimated the playground would open by summer 2028.