CB7 committee backs Fourth Avenue rezoning with conditions

Community Board 7’s Land Use and Landmarks Committee voted 6–3 to support the proposed rezoning application for 783 Fourth Ave. at its Sept. 30 public meeting. The “yes” vote included a list of conditions for the proposed development at the site of the former St. Rocco’s Church complex.
If the project is approved in its current form, three buildings would replace the current church, rectory and school.
The Uniform Land Use Review Procedure, or ULURP, is New York City’s formal process for reviewing certain land-use changes, including rezonings. The roughly seven-month process has already begun and includes a full Brooklyn CB7 vote, review by the borough president, the City Planning Commission and the City Council.
Community Board 7 is scheduled for a full vote on the rezoning at its Oct. 21 meeting. If approved through ULURP, the zoning change would take effect. The land is currently zoned M1-1D, a light-manufacturing district where residential development is limited. The developer is requesting a zoning change required to build the three residential buildings.
Disclosure: This reporter is a resident of 27th Street and has advocated in the past for its residents.
At the Sept. 30 meeting, numerous people spoke in English, Mandarin and Spanish in support of approving the development, particularly Building C’s 100% below-market rentals. Many of the speakers identified themselves as associated with Fifth Avenue Committee and Brooklyn Tenants United. Fifth Avenue Committee would build and manage Building C.
Echo Lin spoke in Chinese at the CB7 meeting in favor of the proposed development, particularly the affordable apartments. “Every year that has gone by, all I have seen is rent going up, and it is becoming very expensive for me and my family to live in Sunset Park.” Speaking about the hardship of paying rent for her family, she added, “We are rent burdened, and we pay 60% or more of our salary towards rent. Affordable housing for families such as mine would make a huge difference in our family's future.”
Some local activists demanded much deeper affordable housing for all three buildings and presented a petition to CB7 requesting rejection of the proposal as it stands. They said the land had been tax-exempt as part of St. Rocco Church for many years and remains owned by the Diocese of Brooklyn. They said the land is not being sold to the developer but made available through a 100-year lease. The activists argued that this land should not be used for what is primarily a market-rate, for-profit development. The group included the three members of the CB7 Land Use and Landmarks Committee who voted no.
State Assemblymember Marcela Mitaynes also voiced opposition to approval of the rezoning, speaking on Zoom. “This is a better project than we have seen in the past, but I think it's inadequate and not enough, I'd rather us take our time and get it right then say this wasn't good.” Referring to Building C, where most apartments are set at 50% AMI, Mitaynes said, “50% sounds nice, but when our folks need 20% and less, this then becomes inadequate.”
For a family of four, 50% of Area Median Income is $84,800 a year, while 20% AMI is $33,920.
“I urge everyone here to oppose it, I stand in deep opposition of a project that pretends to be providing affordable housing, but in fact is gentrifying the neighborhood,” Dennis Clay said. Clay also called Watermark Capital Group, the developer, “a known, bad actor.”
Members of the 27th Street Block Association said they want housing built on the site but are concerned about the scale of the project, which reaches halfway down 27th Street where the existing buildings are two- and three-story wood-frame and brick townhouses.
“We want to see a real step down into the mid block like other projects in the area have done,” said Ben Lim, speaking on behalf of the 27th Street Block Association. He called Watermark a bad neighbor so far and the current site an “eyesore,” with garbage and debris on the sidewalk in front of the site. “I personally shovel (snow) on the sidewalks in the winter because no one else does.”
Among the conditions, or recommendations, included with the committee’s approval were demands for a rainwater and environmental study; a community benefits agreement; affordability pegged to the square footage of the buildings, rather than the number of apartments, with an overall target of 50%; more two- and three-bedroom rent-reduced apartments; prevailing wages for construction workers; and a setback on Building B that feels in scale with the neighborhood.
St. Rocco’s Church was decommissioned in 2019. Watermark Capital Group has pursued residential redevelopment of other former church properties.
The proposed three buildings are known in the plans as A, B and C. Buildings A and B would be built first and managed by Watermark. They would rise 13 and 9 stories, both on 27th Street. According to the proposal presented at the meeting, 23% and 25%, respectively, of the apartments would rent below market rate.
Building C, built later, would be constructed and managed by the Brooklyn nonprofit Fifth Avenue Committee. All apartments would be below market rate. This building, on 28th Street, would reach 8 stories. The total number of units for all three buildings is planned to be 214.
Michelle de la Uz, executive director of Fifth Avenue Committee, responded via Zoom to calls for deeper affordability. “I would love 100% affordable housing everywhere. Unfortunately, you know, we don't have that much taxpayer dollar available given the current political will that exists either at the city, the state, or at the federal government to do what is needed to address our affordable housing crisis at that scale.”